| Friday December 1st, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Goshen at McNicholas | Goshen | 44 | McNicholas | 59 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Tuesday December 5th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Aiken at McNicholas | Aiken | 43 | McNicholas | 62 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday December 8th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Alter | McNicholas | 37 | Alter | 39 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Tuesday December 12th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Carroll | McNicholas | 58 | Carroll | 27 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday December 15th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Chaminade Julienne at McNicholas | Chaminade Julienne | 29 | McNicholas | 42 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Saturday December 16th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Walnut Hills at McNicholas | Walnut Hills | 58 | McNicholas | 43 | L | 1:00 | Holiday Tournament | Box Score |
| Sunday December 17th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Goshen at McNicholas | Goshen | 29 | McNicholas | 50 | W | TBD | Holiday Tournament | Box Score |
| Friday December 22nd, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Elder at McNicholas | Elder | 55 | McNicholas | 32 | L | 3:30 | | Box Score |
| Thursday December 28th, 2023 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Loveland | McNicholas | 42 | Loveland | 50 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Wednesday January 3rd, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Covington Catholic | McNicholas | 33 | Covington Catholic | 48 | L | 5:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday January 5th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Badin | McNicholas | 39 | Badin | 45 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Tuesday January 9th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at LaSalle | McNicholas | 30 | LaSalle | 70 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday January 12th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Fenwick at McNicholas | Fenwick | 37 | McNicholas | 64 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday January 19th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Alter at McNicholas | Alter | 67 | McNicholas | 34 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday January 26th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Carroll at McNicholas | Carroll | 27 | McNicholas | 52 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Saturday January 27th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Turpin at McNicholas | Turpin | 54 | McNicholas | 51 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Friday February 2nd, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Chaminade Julienne | McNicholas | 41 | Chaminade Julienne | 52 | L | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Saturday February 3rd, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Anderson | McNicholas | 55 | Anderson | 40 | W | 1:00 | | Box Score |
| Friday February 9th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| Badin at McNicholas | Badin | 38 | McNicholas | 61 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Tuesday February 13th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Roger Bacon | McNicholas | 49 | Roger Bacon | 41 | W | 4:30 | | Box Score |
| Saturday February 17th, 2024 |
| Teams | Visitor | Score | Home | Score | W-L | Time | Alternate Location | Game Box |
| McNicholas at Fenwick | McNicholas | 43 | Fenwick | 60 | L | 12:00 | | Box Score |
| | | | | | | | | |
